Sunday, January 27, 2008

Papua New Guinea and Speech Situation/ Event of our Classroom

I found Kros to be very fascinating. I can’t help but contrast it to the way in which we Westerners express anger. Although we all have different ways of conveying our anger, I wonder if we too have a defined way in which we each individually express it. The people of Papua New Guinea have a defined understanding (norm) in which they let others know that they are upset with someone. This leads me to question whether or not our context for expressing anger is the same. We may yell and curse when we are angry, but we are also passive aggressive and possibly vindictive. If we had Kros in the United States, how would that change the way in which we deal with conflict?

In our classroom, our Speech Event and Situation are a bit different than other classrooms. Although it is the same in its structure, (Come to class, take notes, do homework etc.) it is more loosely defined than many of my other classes. The power structure between Tiffany and the students is more relaxed and open. I feel that Tiffany is willing to relate to us on own level, and in return it creates a different reaction from the students. We give respect and control to her, yet we know that we a big part of the conversation as well. That’s another thing, our Speech Situation is different in the sense that we are in more of a conversation than a lecture. Because we analyze many things that we as students have never thought about before, we are all learning from both the teacher and from one another. I appreciate this class because it is different in its structure, which encourages me to learn and participate in a different way than I am used to.

8 comments:

Dathan said...

"I feel that Tiffany is willing to relate to us on own level, and in return it creates a different reaction from the students."

This is kind of an interesting way to phrase what you want to say... For me, as I get to be an older student in the classroom I tend to disassociate from the inherent hierarchy of teacher/student.

I have a family, I own a house, I run a business. I may be a student - but in some instances, I could teach the class better than the professor. By the way, this isn't one of those classes - I completely respect Tiffany and her teaching methods.

So- I fully see what you are saying and in fact, I agree with your observation - Just interesting how it relates differently to other students.

Courtney Johansen said...

"The power structure between Tiffany and the students is more relaxed and open." I think it's interesting that, simply by referring to the teacher by her first name, you are giving an example of how relaxed our classroom is.

aeinquiry said...

Despite having some positive sentiments about the Kros, I think it is important to remember that this particular social ritual was built by thousands of years of a society, I assume, closed by tribal affiliation and village. A kros simply could not function in American society because Americans lack the social cohesion of the aforementioned. Who would hear this kros? Your neighbors? Are all of them familiar with you?

cjudkin2 said...

If we were to practice Kros in the United States I do not think much would change. It would be great if we could solve our conflicts through words, but it is not very realistic.

Dathan said...

Actually, I think I've seen a form of the Kros used in the US... It resulted in a restraining order and charges of disturbing the peace...

Shawn D said...

I think that the class room does have a very relaxed environment. Flower picked up on how we feel comfortable calling the teacher by her first name. I am a bit uncomfortable calling teachers by there first name because I have always been taught not to. It was always established that they were not your friend but your instructor.

I think people in general have realized that if you make your classroom more relaxed, students feel more comfortable approaching the teacher with questions. It becomes easier to trust your instructor if you feel that your question is slightly ridiculous.

Bentley the Kid said...

I think that Americans often hold in their anger, sometimes at their own expense. I am not advocating that we use "kros". All I am saying is that we should look for ways to address that which is bothering us without having to make a scene.

Hosam said...

I concure and I read some other of these comment and this is awsome. I think the US should adopt Kros!!